|
4 Infantry call-ins is probably too much for a single commander, I'd probably replace one of them with the Booby Trap from Urban Defence. Some pretty cool ideas though! You could maybe use some of those idea for other commanders like Reserve Army as well to spice them up if there is ever another commander revamp... |
I am confused why it needs to have 0.75 moving accuracy? This and the build time should be easy changes. If possible it should also get a cooldown like heavy tanks. I would also make it slightly more expensive (10 fuel maybe?) and remove the HP buff at vet 3.
In my experience Puma has a field day with Valentine. The .75 accuracy is the only thing that lets you chase after them without getting kited to death. Since accuracy doesn't help you against infantry I think it's fine given the high % that Valentine will bounce against mediums. I do agree that the HP buff at Vet 3 probably isn't needed. |
OP: can you just take a bit more time into thinking why the suggestion is bad?
I guess we are going to have 2 more threads.
Volks changes and Rifles changes. Not like they need anything.
 Beat me to it.
Personally I'm shocked to learn that balance is SO bad right now that almost every mainline infantry unit is broken...
|
USF is good in 1v1, but since team games focus so much in late game artillery there is not much USF can offer beside the doctrinal Calliope.
This is USF team game meta in a nutshell. You are basically forced to tech Capt and camp with Pak Howies or go Calliope. Otherwise you just get slowly bled by artillery late game with forward trucks supporting ISGs being particularly troublesome on some 2v2 maps. Scotts are fine in some circumstances but can't punish support weapon concentrations or delete squads reliably. I feel like Scotts need their barrage tweaked to better fill a late game role and/or get some kind of White Phosphorus barrage at Vet 2 or something so that you can actually force retreats and punish truck city concentrations. |
I did some testing. It generally does not go out side the radius. It does have a higher change of impacting near by terrain. I believe the flight pattern is at fault here
Preferred_height_approach is 15 and the preferred_height_dive is also 15. This makes the IL comes in and stays low. More rounds hit buildings and trees
In comparison to the stuka,
Preferred_height_approach is 30 and the preferred_height_dive is 18. The angle of approach and the higher altitude makes less rounds impact the environment.
Additionally, the lower angle allows the scatter to much more pronounced, relying on more of colliding then impact.
Balance, wise, yes it is very weak. More suppression needed.
Thanks for testing. Even if you just make it more reliable by a simple fix of the angle then that would go a long way though you could obviously reduce CP or do other things to make it more attractive. So sad because this commander has so much potential... |
What kind of retarded argument is what?
Ost has snare from the very start of the game, yet allies still can use lights against them and multiple grens provide more snare opportunities then singular engi appearing at 5th minute.
Sorry sarcasm wasn't strong enough  |
|
OP does bring valid point though why can't OST get 222 before Royal engineers? I mean shit... Brits already OP AND they can have snares available before your light vehicle!? |
|
IDK I don't think it's rocket science why 5 men Grens are popular. You get extra survivability with 5th man on top of additional RA with upgrade. It's a super user friendly upgrade that also makes them suck less hard as close range vs. Rifles and Cons - they don't perform super well at close range but they don't get dumpstered as hard as LMG grens. I don't think that necessarily means that are OP - maybe just better than LMG and G43 grens in some cases which I think is okay for an ability on just one commander. |
|
What Aero said. Ass Grens into PGrens mean they have no snares so M20, Vickers UC (spam the suppress ability), and Flamer clown car wreck these strategies. Doctrinally the USF Jeep and M5 meatchopper also help out (M5 meatchoppers also forces off 222s and Flamer HTs if they go that route) |
USF's Assault M3 or a WC51 with unique abilities would be cool and allow the group to be cheaper. Clearly the answer is to make them come in the British Special weapons M3 so that you can give Vickers to your Penals  |
0
EtherealDragon
DeadConan
Relic Entertainment
Zyswen 
T.R. Opportunity Cost 
