Profile of Highfiveeeee

1- Many new players are already only playing compstomp

In this case, the problem isn't that much of a problem itself. Playing against the AI will never lead in such a stress like playing against real enemies will. The AI will not use cheese against you, it's too dumb for that. It is possible (and fun) to play against the AI with every "standard" commander with good chances to win. You will see, if you use the cheese tactics you learned from ranked games, even a hard AI will have absolutely zero chances.

2- You can use this method sometime when you are waiting friends to play
Nobody says getting a new commander should be easy, but logical = you play, you are sure to get a commander after a period of time, and the one you really want.

Yeah, but realistically you do this maybe once or twice while waiting, not in a regular case.

The logic behind "you play = you get a commander" is correct but you can also say "you walk = you will arrive in China one day" - It is much MUCH more comforting to simply pay real money ( = buy a plane ticket). Nobody will walk to China by foot because it's too much stress. And also hardcore grinding is CoH2 is also absolutely no pleasure.

Now you also have to consider the game cost 20euros on steam and can probably be found aroud 10 euros on different stores or even less during sold. So in the end, you can buy it really cheap and invest 10 more euros on commanders (which are also many times sold). All of that for half of the price other players paid for the same stuff.

That justification is questionable. Only because other players paid 20€ for a game and you paid 10€ does not mean that your wallet gives you a buffer. You bought the game because you saw a deal and wouldn't have bought it for 20€. That also includes that you won't be willing to invest your savings into stuff for the game. With this explanation you could also say that those freemium mobile games are the best. You get the game for free, so you automatically get a 10€ (or whatever the game experience is "worth") buffer from your wallet and your mind, but this is not the case.

CoH2 does NOT cost 10/20/whatever euros because it is a "free" 2 play game, but because it is more than three years old. It would be understandable (or better: "somehow" understandable) if CoH2 released for 10€ with the addition that extra commanders cost extra money. But it released as a full priced game with additional buyable content that gives you massive advantages. Usually games are either full priced and come with everything from the start (except skins, which don't change the gameplay) OR are completely free from the start and you pay for ingame stuff (like most mobile games).
CoH2 cost full price on release, which is 60€ where I live AND demanded even more money if you wanted to stay somehow comparable to other players in higher ranks. This. is. not. acceptable.

We can also compare it with a MMORPG, you can be a new player and reach level max on any mmo game and still you'll not be equal to others which have been there for long time. You'll need time to grind your stuff and any time you face one of those better stuffed player, you'll probably die fast whenever you are better or not.

In MMORPGs there are different areas for low level players where everyone is around your level. The game supports you (at least a bit) in the grinding process. You get different quests and stuff, but grinding in CoH2 is playing the same match over and over again. What would help here would be a rewarding system like "You killed more than 200 soldiers in this match, here take 150 Extra Points", but this is not implemented because it would weaken the sales if there were "more acceptable" forms of grinding.

Also in MMORPGs you will never face an enemy that is 50 levels above you (only if you walk to the respective area because you are an idiot haha), but in CoH2 the player base is so small that the game will give you a player that is much better than you are, if it doesn't fit a better fitting player in a specific time frame.

Today in Coh2, USF/OKW/Sov have commanders from the get to go that are clearly fine, Ostheer maybe not (don't remember which were free) but we hope the patch will change that in some way. Brit I dunno as I don't have the faction. And Honestly at low level till top 500, except from some hypothetical noob-killer commanders, improving your skill will always be superior than getting a new commander.

You might be right in terms of Soviets, but USF has Calliope, which is OP and not available from the start and UKF has Land Mattress. OKW has fortifications, but overall the OKW commanders from the go are fine. Ostheer has Elite Troops and Mechanized Assault which are both meta and not available.

Or you compstomp 1vs1 Easy Computer and you end the game in 10 minutes.
Or you compstomp 1vs1 Computer and you surrender at 5 minutes (but only get 1500pts)
Or you play vs a partner and you surrender every 5 minutes one after the other.

Your only limit is the amount of supply you can get every day, which I don't remember the total.

I think your game needs to be at least about 10 minutes long in order to get any Loot.
So even if you compstomp all the time easy PCs (which is soooooo much fun Kappa) you still need 25% of my calculated time, which is still about 15 - 20 hours of pure nonstop compstomping.

No sane person will do that.

Bring the patch faster, just bring it online. Why not? Balance is terrible in favor for Allies actually

Not their decision, it's Relics.

Same as the scope. OP p2w units such as the Calliope and the Land Mattress need to stay OP in order to make money. Same with Pershing and Comet.

I missed blizzard so much. This was actually one of the coolest innovations in gameplay. Something new, something different from vCoH. Like TrueSight, like all this little things, which makes winter more real. Now it is in the past.

It was an interesting concept but implemented extremely poorly.
The goal was to encourage flanks and surprise attacks but in reality you couldn't do anything because moving away from your campfires meant death by freezing for your infantry, leaving your vehicles behind unsupported. So everyone just waited for 2-3 minutes, did nothing ingame, maybe went to the toilet or get something from the fridge.

In addition because of the poor engine of the game, framerates dropped to below 20 fps on even the best high end PCs while a Blizzard occurred.