|
Having played the free weekend, I just wanted to add my 2 cents about the current state of CoH3.
The TLDR is: It's pretty good now, at the very least for MP. As an average gamer, if you liked CoH2 you can buy CoH3 and have a good time. Can't talk much about SP. Skirmish is definitely fine, but it has been a while since I played the campaigns (although to be honest I believe the narration of the North Africa one is beyond fixable).
I have been skeptic for quite a while about CoH3. I've basically played every time Relic promoted the game with a free weekend. The open alpha before official release, which I thought had a good base but overall difficult to play and making me slightly disoriented in the game and even dizzy afterwards), the free weekend in mid 2025 and the one now.
In 2025 I felt it was an okay game, but the art style, graphics, effects, sound etc all where not at the level that I want from a CoH game. CoH2 had a good gameplay loop (although it was repetitive and also had its own issues), but just the pure cinematics of this game put it on another level. Every time something hit, you could really feel it in your bones. Hearing the previously humming engine of your tank roar up as you send it into battle just does something special. And despite it being an arcade game, it still transported this dark gritty feeling pretty well. It has been exactly this feeling that I've been looking for, and CoH3 at the time didn't have it. It felt like an okay game on its own, but not the feeling that I would start a CoH game for.
So how does the current free weekend change my view? To be honest, it is still not quite up to CoH2 level in regards to grit, dirtiness and the "in the battle" feeling. But it's getting pretty close. The game doesn't come off to me as the cartoony version it was before around release and even in mid 2025, but as an actual war game. The sound is improved and while not as varied as CoH2 overall pretty decent. Some of the animations still look weird (as some did in CoH2), but you most of these you only notice these while watching, not while playing. Same for e.g. the smoke that looked way better in CoH2. But many are simply better, nicer, smoother compared to the predecessor. Vehicles and the damage they take look great, terrain and houses look phenomenal. Although I couldn't dive deeply into the game, gameplay looked a hundred times better as well. CoH2 was centered a lot around tech timings. Miss your tech and you're toast, light vehicles didn't matter once mediums hit the field. CoH3 at least for now doesn't feel that way. Most vehicles stay relevant and have secondary functions, infantry is more varied, and you have a lot of choices to make to suit your playstyle. Each factions has their gimmick that they are centered around. It overall works pretty beautifully together. The battlegroups are much more interesting and allow me to choose and prioritize over commanders which just passively unlock things.
I haven't been meta-slaving like I sometimes tried in CoH2. I don't even know the current meta. These times are over anyway, I won't follow the meta and just play what I feel like. And despite not knowing the game and just re-using old reflexes from CoH2, I have won a decent amount of MP matches. So yes, there are enough players like me looking for games as well, don't worry about MP being all sweaty. There is a place for us casuals, too.
I've been converted. I'll play CoH3 from now onwards.
See you on the battlefield. |
|
This thread is a fever dream |
according to your playercard, you are a 1800 ELO DAK-only hero in 4v4.
THESE are the winrates of 4v4 at your ELO range in patch 2.0

Yet somehow you come here claiming that axis are weak. Looks like you really are kinda bad at a game that's already made for the inept, with the dumbest faction to top it all off.
There's still a bar visible for Allies. Must be OP then! |
I'm surprised you're reaching this verdict, sounds and VFX are still extremely lackluster in CoH3 imo. Guns and explosions still sound mostly the same and pretty dull (with a few notable exceptions such as the USF HMGs for example) and you can't really tell them apart sound-wise.
And most of the explosions look like a small canister of black powder exploding in the sand with a bit of dust & smoke added to it.
That's why I didn't say that both aspects are great all around. Maybe I will change my mind after playing more, but for the couple of skirmishes neither visual nor sound effects had glaring issues to me. Some look a bit off such as mortars, but those I mostly noticed when watching gameplay, not when playing myself. Others like vehicle explosions and a few larger offmaps that I have seen looked really good.
Similar opinion on sound design. Some parts are a bit dull, but real weapons also sound fairly dull. I cann see the argument of CoH needing to sound beefier, but the current sound is not an issue for me for the game. Just not its strong point. Not being able to tell weapons apart definitely is an issue, but I didn't play enough to really notice. |
|
Mostly referring to the people that still are/were doubtful if CoH3 is really the game they want to spend money on after the desastrous launch 2 years ago. Did anyone of you test it and now decide to either buy or not buy the game? What's your verdict at the moment?
I managed to play three skirmishes and was pleasantly surprised. Before launch, I tested the alpha (obviously not good), later played parts of the DAK campaign during a free weekend (campaign bad, gameplay was okay but not great) and now another three AI skirmishes. And this time around, the game was pretty good. Still lacks a bit of the oomph that CoH2 had, but at least part of that is by design such as the increased TTK and overall brighter maps generating a less oppressive feeling. But it's not lacking much, and not in many places. Many other details are really well done. I remember getting dizzy when playing the alpha version and everything looking flat and boring in the first free weekend. That's all fixed, most explosions look good to great, sound design is decent, model design is pretty good and especially the vehicles and wrecks look stunning.
Can't judge much on balance, but the game is pretty overwhelming in the beginning due to a large tech and unit variety. Looks promising in that regard.
Lastly, optimization is very well done. Playing on an older system that is usually CPU bottlenecked, I did not notice significant drops during the game, mostly running even 50-70 FPS on max settings (except anti aliasing).
I still won't buy (yet). Sole reason is that I am currently stuck in other games. But CoH3 has moved from 'pass/when on sale' to the will buy later list. For everyone having the same doubts I had, the game is really solid. It feels different from CoH2, but unless you expect a carbon copy ith better graphics, you won't be disappointed |
|
I just played CoH3 on the free weekend, but it feels like retreating is a 99% guarantee to get your squad out alive if it starts with at least somewhat decent health. CoH2 was pretty unforgiving though. |
Thread: Skyrim 3 Nov 2024, 13:04 PM
Did Bethesda rererererererererelease it again? |
|
The 7th man upgrade is effectively a weapon and overall utility upgrade, increasing squad size, damage, survivability and gives a special buff when in cover. The description is true once upgraded, before the upgrade not so much. Although given the cheap price of reinforcement, you're usually gaining an upper hand if your opponent decides to do a drawn out cover-to-cover engagement against Conscripts. |
I always open some dead forum and search for threads from almost 6 years ago
Even worse: You open a dead forum and then get reminded that January 2019 will soon be 6 years. Fucking hell time flies... |
|
As Rosbone said, I think the lighting settings are different in both versions of the map. CoH3 has more cloudy/overcast setting, whereas Elst in CoH2 appears to be a sunny summer day. Maybe a shadow comparison with a sunny map on CoH3 would have been better. Also, the sun has changed its position between CoH2 and CoH3 Elst. Just to be totally correct, the camera angle towards the sun should be roughly similar, because it will affect reflections.
This doesn't change Rosbone's conclusion though. CoH3 looks a bit flat overall, and in my layman's opinion lighting seems to be a major issue. The texture and model quality is pretty nice overall.
The main problem that CoH3 has is that CoH2, with all its faults in gameplay and design, is actually an absolutely astonishing game in terms of aesthetics and feel. Matching this level of quality is hard for any game, so CoH3 now gets criticized for not being picture perfect, while overall still being solid. |