Ostheer vs USF is a tough matchup for the Ostheer no matter how good or bad you are.
One of the Ways to minimize this is by picking(or buying...) a Doctrine with a Tiger Tank. Out of all the tiger doctrines Mechanized Assault is the best.
You have 0 docs with a Tiger which puts you a disadvantage,right from the loading screen. You can win without a tiger but its really hard. In a way this is Pay to win,unfortunately..
First things first,CAPPING ORDER. As ostheer,you need to consolidate your units to the section of the map that has:
1 VP to minimize victory point bleed
1 Muni point,
1 Fuel Point,
And your cut off points.
(note on all maps this isnt possible,Semoisky is one of the worst maps for Ostheer,refer to
Map veto guide for more info on that)
Send ALL YOUR AVAILABLE forces to this section of the map that has all these things,and try to hold these specific points until you knock out or nullify the light vehicle from lieutenant tier.(which means hold these points for the first 6-7 minutes,and THEN spread out)
Spreading out too early makes it really easy for the USF to pick you apart,since on an individual basis your units are inferior,but together with combined arms they can handle USF units with ease.
Your unit response to the fighting position was appropriate (a mortar). dont walk MGs near fighting positions. just wait for your mortar and hold your fuel and muni.
Because you didnt consolidate your defenses near your supplies,you were easily isolated and picked apart,and your cutoff and fuel was taken. You didnt make an effort to take it back either. Combine your forces like you did in the middle of the map,
around your fuel instead.
at around 13 minutes,if you HAD MECHANIZED ASSAULT,you wouldve been able to squeeze out a STUG E instead of teching and buying a tank. You wouldve MURDERED him if you had a STUG E at this point.
When he shot your Stug through the Hedge he was using Attack Ground. You can shoot through hedges like that and hit units on the other side. You couldve done the same thing to him with your Stug.
By the way the stug was in a horrible position. Put a teller mine on that road to cover that approach instead of wasting a unit there.
Also you're failing to break through because you have no tiger.
Get a tiger doc get a tiger doc get a tiger doc
The squad wipes were deserved, you tried to attack a Scott,and 2 shermans with 2 panzershreks and no armor support,what were you expecting? had you given up at that point?
again having a tiger would help alot of your problems.
I came to the conclusion that Alot of your problems were from not having a good
Tiger doc like mechanized assault.to be honest...you have decent fundamentals,and your micro could be better(you can always improve,we all can :v),but you outplayed this guy this game,and he wasnt very smart. You just lacked the proper late game units to get the job done. (BUY MECHANIZED ASSAULT AND PLAY THE SAME WAY! Youll do fine!)
Plant teller mines on flanks instead of placing actual units there.
I swear im not some marketer from relic.
you really need mechanized assault against usf.
BUY THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And if my analysis was not enough :
Mechanized assault Guide