I think this thread could have benefited from a poll, with all the 4v4 maps in automatch listed. I could add one now, but it's probably too late, since most interested contributors will have moved on and won't vote.
I'd disagree, my intention was simply a grumble about some of the 4v4s I've been having. I really doubt they'll ever be fixed, or many more interesting maps added.
My top list
Montargis - for reasons that have been well discussed.
Steppes - because time and again I'm placed to fight on that fricking island.
City 17 - I dunno why, but with bases a long way away and not much opportunity for interesting gameplay, I just find my games become a slug fest.
Hamburg - Seems to be decided in the first 5 minutes in my experience. Never seen a comeback, usually has a lot of drops.
Hills maps - Never had a very good game on either.
Maps that I actually like.
Lienne Forest - I know... I know... but I usually (when my team aren't completely stupid) have a good time on this map.
Lorch Assault - Likewise, the city fighting and broad front is pretty enjoyable.
General Mud - I dunno why, but I also generally have a good time on this map too.
Steppes - When I'm not fighting on that damn island.