Sage used Findeed name for ages and even talked alot of bm while doing so.
... and got permabanned multiple times on different accounts for it in the end. See entry #4 :
https://www.coh2.org/topic/52964/list-of-players-suspended-banned-by-relic/post/725206
About the grey areas and vague rules, I agree with all of you basically. But one thing is pretty certain:
You cannot get banned just for copying a Steam name unless it's Relic Staff name. There needs to be additional abusive behavior, in a way so that the person is clearly attempting to damage the reputation of the name that they duplicated.
Now in Kimbo's case, only Relic knows the exact reason. But there is multiple possible scenarios, such as:
- playing arranged team with a seeking smurf while using Luvnest's name was interpreted as attempted reputation damage
- the whole player impersonation as reason was just a "placeholder" for a different reason such as playing with a cheater
- etc.
OK i show you one of my smurfs banned from back in the day, just because im a nice guy.
Ok so one of my assumptions might be wrong, cool. But it really doesn't matter. We're arguing about something that isn't the core of the topic.
Relic doesn't have to tell you the exact details about the ban. You were walking on thin ice when you decided to change your name while playing with Seeking, and you knew that. Not to mention that there might be ban-worthy incidents that we don't know about because it happened off-stream.
It's not our business, so what is even the point of this thread other than you throwing a tantrum *again* after being timebanned for what feels like the 3rd or 4th time now

(congrats, that is quite an achievement Kimbo)