That's why they won the war right?
You're wrong about the Tiger scene though, because an Easy 8 with its 76mm could have punched through that Tiger's front at the range they first encountered it.
Sorry, but the shitty box design of the P4 and Tiger were outdated shortly after the war started. Please put away Mein Kampf and come back to reality.
Not sure why you imply REforever would be a Nazi, but i'm pretty sure that fancy tanks won't automatically win you a war.
Kinda curious where you got your information from. A 76mm M1 couldn't penetrate a Tiger front properly, especially not at 800(?) yards. Good, but rare, HVAP were mostly used for designated TDs.
Anyways...
Even though i would have liked to see a more large scale Sherman vs. Tiger scene, with less errors and common sense mistakes, it definitely was at least enjoyable and nicely made, unlike the final scene - i can only assume they were drunk or something.