So why you don't called out MMX for posting wrong data about the time a 76mm needs to destroy a Panther? Aren't his diagramms misleading?
Imo they are not and neither is my post if you factor in the coherences and relations of the discussion. my post was clearly pointing to his data, because I took his numbers for Sherman for a direct comparison. In a direct comparison it makes no sense to add another factor which wasn't used to calculate the data you want to compare to. It is only misleading if you take the post for itself and don't take the time to read the post it is related to.
This line of arguing is non constructive, I have no personal issue with you and I it was not my intention to insult you in anyway. If you have been insulted by something I have posted pls point from what and I will take it into consideration.
Having that said MMX has:
1) Pointed out that his graphs do not take accuracy into consideration
2) Has used the graphs to compare the 76mm AP round with HAVP and not draw conclusions about Panther/76mm Fights.
3) he has posted a high quality post stating fact instead of posting an opinion.
As I said I would rather stop here and not continue down this path...
Its not even of any importance if it is just an overlapping issue or a balance one. The outcome is the same. 76mm has no place in USF tank roster. It needs a redesign along with 2-3 other units/abilities in this commander. I proposed some ways it could be done. Noone speaks about creating a balance issue.
You have suggested changes that are buff and can create balance issues. I have already pointed out that WC51 with Cav riflemen passenger can cuase balance issue especially in OKW 1vs1.
Its just you who smells trouble if someone says "Can we revive the last choosen commander in USF commander loadout, please?".
You should be aware that this is again false since I already have made my suggestions on how to redesign the commander pls avoid this line of arguing.
What I have said is that imo WC51 and 76mm are already balanced units that do not require buffs so buffing them is not path in making the commander more attractive.