Login

russian armor

OKW, the root of most balance issues?

PAGES (17)down
13 Dec 2014, 17:29 PM
#281
avatar of ZombiFrancis

Posts: 2742

For OKW shreks are a no brainer. As Ostheer I'm often a little leery of dumping 120 munitions into something that is more likely going to give my opponents shreks.

Bah I wish I could just get one on pgrens. Half the squad having shreks translates directly into 'drop as many shreks as possible for the enemy on retreat!' most of the time.
13 Dec 2014, 18:30 PM
#282
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17875 | Subs: 8

Shrecks are no brainer, because there is no decision making for OKW.
No choosing between upgrades, no vehicle upgrades, nothing.

OKW as a whole is a no brainer design, the only decision making is puma or medics first.
13 Dec 2014, 18:34 PM
#283
avatar of gokkel

Posts: 542

Ugh the handicapped economy thing again. Hasnt this been shown time and again as really no handicap or do we need to go over that again.


The only times I have seen people write about it in this forum it has been done by people without any further reasoning apart from "oh but OKW has ressource transfer" (which obviously just means you handicap your other ressource even further) or people who don't even understand basic mathematics and use wrong multiplicator to normalize costs. Or they assume that reduced teching costs makes up for everything because you apparently only ever build one vehicle per game. So please go ahead.

And yes it will change things.


Really? You think people won't just start (or rather continue) complaining about these things next?

-Volksgrenadiere Schreck blobs destroy tanks!
-Flak Headquarter damages tanks!
-Jagdtiger is too powerful!
-Stuka is too precise and kills units and is too difficult to destroy!
-Kübelwagen is ruining the game!
-Panzerfüsiliers are too strong! (depending on how heavy Obersoldaten nerf is more people might just switch to those)
-Puma is sniping vehicles, has more penetration than medium tanks in close range, has smoke launcher and is too fast!
-Panther has armor like a heavy tank and mobility like a medium tank and the machine guns kill infantry, my Jackson doesn't penetrate it with every hit!
-King Tiger has too much armor!
-King Tiger comes too early in team games with fuel drops from team mates!


That is even before we consider buffing some of the remaining units (as was suggested as a trade off for nerfing Obersoldaten). What you think will happen if we buff units not mentioned in this list yet?

-How can OKW start with such a powerful unit as Sturmpioniere? (remember how people complained about them in the past already?)
-Raketenwerfer comes at T0, is the cheapest anti tank gun and demolishes vehicles and it can even enter buildings, what is this?
-AA Halftrack is now as absurdly powerful as USF AA Halftrack, how am I meant to kill it without a Puma?
-Jagdpanzer IV is so much better than SU-85 and Jackson!
-leIG, well, just remember how people complained before it got nerfed
-Sturmtiger kills my whole army!


I will just skip the other doctrinal units.
13 Dec 2014, 18:36 PM
#284
avatar of NinjaWJ

Posts: 2070

overpowered things will be nerfed. It is silly to have an overpowered unit due to some handicap or whatnot (plus Obers aren't even affected by the resource penalty).

THis was the exact logic applied to the jagdtiger. It was OP and very frustrating for players o deal with because the unit shot through all sorts of shot blockers. In this case, the Jagdtiger is affected by the resource penalties, but this doesn't mean that its overpowered nature stayed.


The goal of the game developers, i am certain, is to have a fun and balanced game. THis applies to all units, and all factions.
13 Dec 2014, 18:56 PM
#285
avatar of gokkel

Posts: 542

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 18:36 PMNinjaWJ
overpowered things will be nerfed. It is silly to have an overpowered unit due to some handicap or whatnot (plus Obers aren't even affected by the resource penalty).

THis was the exact logic applied to the jagdtiger. It was OP and very frustrating for players o deal with because the unit shot through all sorts of shot blockers. In this case, the Jagdtiger is affected by the resource penalties, but this doesn't mean that its overpowered nature stayed.


The goal of the game developers, i am certain, is to have a fun and balanced game. THis applies to all units, and all factions.


Obersoldaten are not affected by the resource penalty, of course they are not, they are just the consequence for the resource penalty. Relic made an extremely powerful infantry unit that OKW can still afford to buy with their handicapped munition and fuel income to compensate for everything OKW lacks in their other units to fight infantry. This may be absurd but this is what we have right now. Don't you think Relic normally would have already nerfed this unit to the ground seeing how many complaints there are about this unit since release of WFA?
13 Dec 2014, 19:25 PM
#286
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17875 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 18:56 PMgokkel

Don't you think Relic normally would have already nerfed this unit to the ground seeing how many complaints there are about this unit since release of WFA?

You mean... like ISU or JT for example?

Its op, the question is not 'if' but 'when'.
13 Dec 2014, 19:26 PM
#287
avatar of NinjaWJ

Posts: 2070

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 18:56 PMgokkel


Obersoldaten are not affected by the resource penalty, of course they are not, they are just the consequence for the resource penalty. Relic made an extremely powerful infantry unit that OKW can still afford to buy with their handicapped munition and fuel income to compensate for everything OKW lacks in their other units to fight infantry. This may be absurd but this is what we have right now. Don't you think Relic normally would have already nerfed this unit to the ground seeing how many complaints there are about this unit since release of WFA?


I'm not saying Obers shouldn't be good, they are 400 mp, but right now imo they are too good.

Sometimes Relic doesn't even care if there are tons of user complaints. Look at how many people asked for the SU76 to be viable again. This hasn't been changed for over a year
13 Dec 2014, 19:31 PM
#288
avatar of gokkel

Posts: 542

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 19:25 PMKatitof

You mean... like ISU or JT for example?

Its op, the question is not 'if' but 'when'.


Good point, they are a bit slow and too hesitating with it but at least they do something about it every other patch. Not so with Obersoldaten. You would think they had the perfect opportunity when they nerfed all LMGs, but guess which LMG unit got the smallest nerf and only in exchange for a damage buff on the K98 to compensate?


As I said, I won't complain if they nerf Obersoldaten and overhaul the faction design. I just don't think either allied or OKW players will be happy if Relic just nerfs Obersoldaten and don't change anything about the overall faction design.
13 Dec 2014, 19:44 PM
#289
avatar of Jaigen

Posts: 1130



They are far too potent. They need to be adjusted. Even if they increase other units DPS if they for example turn out to break OKW. I even like the Kappatch that simply reduced the LMG and buffed the Kar98 resulting in the same squad DPS. This made them less rapid fire sniper rifles.


You continually say they are too potent but do not say why. or at least nothing that warrants a nerf. in your previous post you mentioned that they can take hmgs from the front. EVERY single lmg unit can take a lmg from the front even that dopey dp.

and killing light vehicles is nothing new as once again every lmg is good at it . and countering infantry is their speciality
13 Dec 2014, 19:49 PM
#290
avatar of Enkidu

Posts: 351

Obers drastically over preform for price. There may have once been a reason for that in beta but no longer. The problem with a single weapon like the lmg-34 having such high dps is that not only do obers have great defensive stats, when every burst kills a model, they quickly reduce the dps out put of the squads they're fighting, further improving their survivability.

Obers are non doctrinal, easy to tech to, have no muni cost, have insane dps that can be done at max range, have great defensive stats compounded by vet and model sniping and are available to a faction with low up keep costs and no shortage of man power. It's fine that they are a strong unit, it's not fine that they are as strong as they currently are with almost no draw backs. They need to be adjusted.
13 Dec 2014, 20:44 PM
#291
avatar of JHeartless

Posts: 1637

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 19:44 PMJaigen


You continually say they are too potent but do not say why. or at least nothing that warrants a nerf. in your previous post you mentioned that they can take hmgs from the front. EVERY single lmg unit can take a lmg from the front even that dopey dp.

and killing light vehicles is nothing new as once again every lmg is good at it . and countering infantry is their speciality


You know I started to pull up the stats. But nah. You can compare them to Airborne yourself. By your logic Airborne must be UP o.O since Obers are obviously fine and barely cost more...
13 Dec 2014, 21:33 PM
#292
avatar of Jaigen

Posts: 1130



You know I started to pull up the stats. But nah. You can compare them to Airborne yourself. By your logic Airborne must be UP o.O since Obers are obviously fine and barely cost more...



You dont have 2 as i really dont give a shit to unit comparison in general. i look how an unit performs generally in the faction. considering the faction has the worst baseline AI fuel and ammo generation it needs the obers.

The obers would be very op in the ostheer. but the ostheer is not the okw and the okw is not the usf and so forth.
13 Dec 2014, 22:07 PM
#293
avatar of Katitof

Posts: 17875 | Subs: 8

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 21:33 PMJaigen



You dont have 2 as i really dont give a shit to unit comparison in general.

Or having a balanced game for that matter.

i look how an unit performs generally in the faction. considering the faction has the worst baseline AI fuel and ammo generation it needs the obers.

Sure it does, but not at that power level.

The obers would be very op in the ostheer. but the ostheer is not the okw and the okw is not the usf and so forth.


And LMG42 would be very op if conscripts had it.
But soviets are not Wehr and wehr is not space aliens.

Whatever you're smoking, it really kicked in good in your last line as its completely detached from the discussion and is not even making a logical argument.
13 Dec 2014, 23:20 PM
#294
avatar of Mr. Someguy

Posts: 4928

gokkel has a point though, people will just continue to complain about OKW until they can no longer fight. People complained about Ostheer since release and now look where they are, they are ridiculously disadvantaged against USF.
13 Dec 2014, 23:59 PM
#295
avatar of NinjaWJ

Posts: 2070

Basically Jaigen doesn't listen to anyone or logic. Jaigen lives in own world
14 Dec 2014, 01:24 AM
#296
avatar of Nuclear Arbitor
Patrion 28

Posts: 2470

gokkel has a point though, people will just continue to complain about OKW until they can no longer fight. People complained about Ostheer since release and now look where they are, they are ridiculously disadvantaged against USF.


making EVERYONE satisfied would require a tiny player base. the trick is to make most people satisfied and address obvious issues. people complain about every faction right now but that doesn't mean it's balanced, it just means that there is something about each faction that someone doesn't like.

i could go on but i don't think i could even attempt to answer how to make things mostly balanced without writing pages.
14 Dec 2014, 01:52 AM
#297
avatar of Jaigen

Posts: 1130

jump backJump back to quoted post13 Dec 2014, 23:59 PMNinjaWJ
Basically Jaigen doesn't listen to anyone or logic. Jaigen lives in own world


Ah excellent! Insults are being hurled and this thread will go down in flames and whatever you posted will not be taken seriously and thus effectively destroying your own thread. Well done mate i salute you for entertaining me//
14 Dec 2014, 01:54 AM
#298
avatar of JHeartless

Posts: 1637

gokkel has a point though, people will just continue to complain about OKW until they can no longer fight. People complained about Ostheer since release and now look where they are, they are ridiculously disadvantaged against USF.


And people complained about USF and they got nerfed. And the things they nerfed were OP. And there are still nerfs they need. OP units need to be balanced. OP factions need to be balanced. Its a process as you know.

Having enough AT and AI in Infantry alone to beat an entire faction isnt balance. Its COH1 Ranger Blobs all over again. It really needs to be fixed. Otherwise what is OKWs disadvantage if they can do with manpower what takes other factions Fuel to do?

I LOVED OKW when they first came out. They were very challenging to play and rewarding. At the time Luchs was the only stinker and Panther wasnt a god but like the Jackson took skill to use properly. Then they buffed Muni and Made the Panther an A Move tank and it lost its appeal to me. Its a shame really.

Now that with Equal map control and conversion with a buffed Panther and Flak Truck they combined with Obers/Shrek blobs its just too much. Without Obers being Gods of all Long range DPS Shrek blobs will be more vulnerable. Or conversly if they removed Shreks teeth then Obers would be vulnerable. But as it stands OKW has too much in the Manpower/Muni part going for it.
14 Dec 2014, 01:55 AM
#299
avatar of Jaigen

Posts: 1130



making EVERYONE satisfied would require a tiny player base. the trick is to make most people satisfied and address obvious issues. people complain about every faction right now but that doesn't mean it's balanced, it just means that there is something about each faction that someone doesn't like.

i could go on but i don't think i could even attempt to answer how to make things mostly balanced without writing pages.


actually no. Their aim should be a balanced game regardless what their customers want because some would totally fuck up balance because of their own biased vieuws. And i suspect you are one of them

That the majority holds a view doesn't are right.
14 Dec 2014, 02:05 AM
#300
avatar of Jaigen

Posts: 1130



And people complained about USF and they got nerfed. And the things they nerfed were OP. And there are still nerfs they need. OP units need to be balanced. OP factions need to be balanced. Its a process as you know.

Safe for the broken suppression fire ability and the range of the flack track not much got changed.

Having enough AT and AI in Infantry alone to beat an entire faction isnt balance. Its COH1 Ranger Blobs all over again. It really needs to be fixed. Otherwise what is OKWs disadvantage if they can do with manpower what takes other factions Fuel to do?

i suspect you have a bad memory as rangers did shit against tanks in coh 1 as bazooka's really struggled penetration the front of even medium armor let alone heavies it was primarily an AI unit that came equipped with elite armor. that got further buffed with veterancy


I LOVED OKW when they first came out. They were very challenging to play and rewarding. At the time Luchs was the only stinker and Panther wasnt a god but like the Jackson took skill to use properly. Then they buffed Muni and Made the Panther an A Move tank and it lost its appeal to me. Its a shame really.

initially the okw where much more powerful then they are now as flacktracks where incredibly powerful back then. also obeers lmg's did 25% more dps


Now that with Equal map control and conversion with a buffed Panther and Flak Truck they combined with Obers/Shrek blobs its just too much. Without Obers being Gods of all Long range DPS Shrek blobs will be more vulnerable. Or conversly if they removed Shreks teeth then Obers would be vulnerable. But as it stands OKW has too much in the Manpower/Muni part going for it.

Too much for you perhaps. Not that this inst a potent combination but its far from unbeatable.
the issue is usually the allied player not using any combined arms or support weapons. since you are complaining about it constantly i would really love to a replay


PAGES (17)down
1 user is browsing this thread: 1 guest

Ladders Top 10

  • #
    Steam Alias
    W
    L
    %
    Streak
Data provided by Relic Relic Entertainment

Replay highlight

VS
  • U.S. Forces flag cblanco ★
  • The British Forces flag 보드카 중대
  • Oberkommando West flag VonManteuffel
  • Ostheer flag Heartless Jäger
uploaded by XXxxHeartlessxxXX

Board Info

534 users are online: 3 members and 531 guests
OKSpitfire, Crecer13, Makros
15 posts in the last 24h
50 posts in the last week
104 posts in the last month
Registered members: 44659
Welcome our newest member, Yourcounselling
Most online: 2043 users on 29 Oct 2023, 01:04 AM